Search Strategies Image

Q3 Web Site Evaluation

9. Web Site Evaluation

Introduction

You have learned how to be a better researcher and even learned some fun facts about the U.S. Constitution. Now we are going to make sure that, as you are doing your research, the resources you find are accurate, up-to-date, and are credible.


I Can Statements

  • find the most reliable resources to use when I do research
  • use an online database (like those in mel.org)
  • use a search engine
  • search safely
  • evaluate web sites

Key Vocabulary

Search engine: A search engine is a computer program that is used to look for information on the Internet.

Database: A database is a collection of pieces of information that is organized and used on a computer.

Currency: Currency is the timeliness of the information.

Relevance: Relevance is the importance of the information for your needs. 

Authority: Authority is the source of the information. 

Accuracy: Accuracy is the reliability, truthfulness, and correctness of the information. 

Purpose: Purpose is the reason the information exists. 

Play the Vocabulary Game below to practice the Key Vocabulary


You can change the Quiz mode to Match, Test, Learn, Flash Cards, Spell using the selection list at the bottom right of the activity that says "Choose a Study Mode." Direct Link

Steps

1. You have learned how to search mel.org and Google. Watch the following video to make a decision on which resource to use when you are doing your research.

Direct link to this video

2. Now you are going to do a search on either a topic you would like to know
more about or one that your teacher has selected for you. Use this document as you go through steps three-eight below. 

3. Using Google, you will conduct a search on the topic. Locate at least two articles on your topic to use for your evaluation. Make sure to copy the citations for your assignment. 

4. You will also choose a database from mel.org and find at least two resources and include them in your evaluation. Make sure to copy the citations for your assignment. 

If you would like the articles to be read to you, downloaded to mp3 or
translated to a different language many of the databases in MeL have the
capability to do so. If you see the following next to an article try them out. Listen

translate

5. You will evaluate the resources you have found in order to determine if your information is accurate and up-to-date.

6. Read the information from Benedictine University. Many librarians are promoting the CRAAP Test to teach students how to evaluate resources. It is most often used to evaluate websites, but the same criteria can be applied to other types of resources as well. 

Currency - the timeliness of information

Relevance - the importance of the information for your needs

Authority - the source of the information

Accuracy - the reliability, truthfulness, and correctness of the content

Purpose - the reason the information exists

7. Watch the short video that describes the CRAAP Test. 

Direct link to this video

8. Using the CRAAP Test, evaluate the resources you found using Google and a Mel database. Complete the assignment using the document from step two. 

9. Open up the expandable block below and learn about hoaxes so you don't fall for one. 

10. There are websites that are designed to fool people and make them think what they have posted is real. It is easy to fall for the hoax because they make their website look so real. They will even create articles about the topic and link to articles to make the site look legitimate. 

11 Test your knowledge using this popular hoax site. Pacific Northwest Tree Octopus

12. Please use the following form to evaluate the Tree Octopus website or another website that your teacher may choose for you. Check out these popular hoax websites as an alternative. 

13. Save the form to your File Space or return it to your teacher in Google Classroom.  

14. Many people pass scams and hoaxes on to others. Don't be part of the problem! 

  • Always evaluate the author and source
  • Be skeptical especially if something does not sound right
  • Check the sources on the website 
  • Don't forward until you fact check

Would you like learning more about evaluating web content?
Here are several resources to check out.

List of Popular Hoax Websites 

Fact Monster- research site for students

Completing this Quest

When you have finished evaluating websites you are ready for the next Quest. 

 Check off this Quest on the 21t4s roadmap 

Go to Quest 4

MITECS  Michigan Integrated Technology Competencies for Students, and

ISTE Standards for Students

3. Knowledge Constructor
a. Plan and employ effective research strategies to locate information and other resources for their intellectual or creative pursuits
b. evaluate the accuracy, perspective, credibility and relevance of information, media, data or other resources
c. curate information from digital resources using a variety of tools and methods to create collections of artifacts or solving authentic problems