Q5: Fake or Real News
Do you know which sites are reporting the truth? Can you tell the difference between real and fake information? When a story is big news, it is often quick to spread. The spread of fake news is often through circular reporting. Fake news spins a tall tale, often seen through our own biases or filter bubbles. How do we know when it’s fact or fiction?
I Can Statements
- tell the difference between real and fake news
- factcheck an article
Embellish: To embellish is to tell stories that are more interesting or entertaining by adding extra details, especially ones that are not true.
Circular Reporting: Circular reporting or false confirmation is a situation where a piece of information appears to come from multiple independent sources, but in fact is coming from only one source.
Filter Bubbles: Filter bubbles according to Dr Seargeant, "are implicated in the spread of fake news because they create conditions in which one-sided and extreme opinions can freely circulate and where information is not easily challenged".
Paparazzi: Paparazzi are photographers who follow famous people to get images for newspapers, magazines, social media, or other outlets.
Play the Vocabulary Game below to practice the Key Vocabulary.
You can change the Quiz mode to Match, Test, Learn, Flash Cards, Spell using the selection list at the bottom right of the activity that says "Choose a Study Mode." Direct Link
Fake news has been around a long time, with journalists or the paparazzi stretching the truth to sell their stories. Consider the true story about two very famous rival newspaper owners in the 1890's, William Randolph Hearst and Joseph Pulitzer. These men fought for the attention of their readers by liberally embellishing stories to sell newspapers.
Today journalism is not much different, with the television media filled with entertainment news, reality TV, and the spread of sensationalized stories on social media. Due to the speed that news can now travel, circular reporting is a new phenomenon that is causing the quick spread of fake news.
1. Watch this video on "How False News Can Spread" and learn more about circular reporting.
2. Circular reporting, or the spread of fake news, can often cause a filter bubble, or a place where our own biases allow fake news to continue to spread with no one questioning the source. During this Quest, you are asked to pop the filter bubble by spotting and defeating the spread of fake news.
3. Watch the video below. These are things you should be looking for as you read articles on the Internet to help you tell the difference between real and fake news.
4. Let’s pop the filter bubble by questioning what we read! If possible, with a partner and do a search on stealing water from the Great Lakes. Find at least two articles on this topic. Using the criteria in the poster above read through the articles and determine how accurate and real the reporting is. Use this Word Template to share with your teacher the answers to your questions.
Answer the following questions:
- Who wrote the article? Are they credible or real?
- What is the copyright date of the article? Are the facts reported matching the copyright date?
- Are there supporting sources? Do the links actually support the story?
- Have experts in the field been connected to the story or authored the information?
5. Share the names and web links to the articles you read with your teacher. Be sure to include the answers to each of the questions in Steps One-Four above.
Fact Check Political Stories
Every day there are political news stories that are published that are deceptive and misleading. There are three fact-checking sites to explore: FactCheck.org, Snopes, and PolitiFact. Compare these sites and select one to use to check whether or not the political article you just read is accurate. These sites monitor the factual accuracy of what is said by major U.S. political players in the form of TV ads, debates, speeches, interviews and news releases.
5. Your assignment is to visit to a popular news site such as CNN, ABC News, Huffington Post, or Fox News. Find a trending political news story. (you might want to find the same story on one or more news sites)
6. Next compare the information with one or more of these fact-checking sites: FactCheck.org, Snopes, or PolitiFact, and see if the story is listed on the site. If not, go back and look for another story to check on. If you can work with two partners you can quickly collect and compare your results together.
7. Use a word processing program to answer the following questions.
- What do the fact-check sites say about your story?
- How accurate is the reporting?
8. If you feel your story seems to be fake and you do not find anything on the fact-checking sites, look to see if you can Ask a Question. You can ask your question by filling out a short form. You will have to give an email address. If you don't have one, ask your parent/guardian or teacher if you can use theirs to have the fact-check site email the answer.
9. Share the story's headline and its URL with your teacher along with the facts about the story. If you sent a question, include the question and the answer once you have received it.
10. An additional resource to watch is a TedTalk "How We can Protect Truth in the Age of Misinformation". It is 15 minutes long and talks about how fake news can sway elections, tank economies and sow discord in everyday life.
- Your teacher may choose to watch this together as a class and discuss afterward.
Interactive Fun - How observant are you?
Test your observational skills with one or more of the following:
- Spot a Troll: You decide if each is an authentic account or a professional troll. After each profile you will review the signs that can help you determine if it's a troll or not. https://spotthetroll.org/start
- FakeOut: Your social media feed has been infected by false information. Your job is to learn the skills of verification, so you can sort fact from fiction.
- Real or Photoshopped?
Photoshop users make the impossible possible, and for that, we thank them for taking creativity to places we never could have dreamed. Some things are so amazing, we're not sure if they're Real or Photoshop. Can you tell? https://landing.adobe.com/en/na/products/creative-cloud/69308-real-or-photoshop/index.html
Grades 10-12 Exploring Actual Examples of Newspaper Bias
This activity is from Common Sense Media.
Before screening the video, ask students to take notes while they watch and to write down the five values.
- Show the Ethical Journalism Network video "The 5 Core Values of Journalism." or
- Optional: Hand out copies of the Society of Professional Journalists Code of Ethics.
View this resource Young Voters Guide to Social Media and the News from Common Sense Media. There are resources for parents and tools for teachers on the site too.
Completing this Quest
Save all your activities in your File Space. After completing, continue using the handy tips you learned for knowing what is real or fake. You can help by not passing on fake news to your friends and family.
I am ready for the next Quest, Advanced Search With Google
Competencies & Standards
MITECS Michigan Integrated Technology Competencies for Students, and
2. Digital Citizen
a. cultivate and manage their digital identity and reputation and are aware of the permanence of their actions in the digital world
b. engage in postive, safe, legal and ethical behavior when using technology, including social interactions online
3. Knowledge Constructor
a. plan and employ effective research strategies to locate information and other resources for their intellectual or creative pursuits
b. evaluate the accuracy, perspective, credibility and relevance of information, media, data or other resources
Websites and Documents
- ABC News
- Ask a Question Fact Check
- Fox News
- Huffington Post
- Real Fake News: Exploring Actual Examples of Newspaper Bias
- Real or Photoshop
- Spot the Troll
- Young Voters Guide to Social Media and the News
Videos from Outside Sources
- Ethical Journalism Network "The 5 Core Values of Journalism" YouTube
- How False News Can Spread YouTube
- TedTalk "How We can Protect Truth in the Age of Misinformation" Video
21t4s Documents & Quizzes